How To Tell If An Opal Is Real?

Opals are unlike any other gem — they shimmer with a kaleidoscope of shifting colors, flashing greens, blues, oranges, and reds. This mesmerizing play of color has inspired jewelry lovers for centuries, making opals a favorite for rings, pendants, and earrings that feel both magical and personal.

But with their popularity comes imitation. From resin look-alikes to glass substitutes, many pieces try to mimic opals’ beauty. If you love jewelry with style and substance, knowing how to tell if an opal is real helps you choose pieces that not only look dazzling but also hold true value.

At Plateau Jewelers in Sammamish, WA, we combine gemological expertise with an eye for fashion, helping you discover opals that elevate your style and your collection.

What Makes a Real Opal So Special?

A real opal isn’t just about sparkle — it’s about movement, depth, and individuality. Each natural opal forms over millions of years, developing unique color flashes that can never be duplicated. That’s why opals are often chosen for statement jewelry pieces where personality matters: bold cocktail rings, dramatic pendants, or one-of-a-kind earrings.

  • Natural opals: Always unique, with irregular patterns and organic depth.

  • Lab-created opals: Grown with the same silica structure, vibrant and stylish, but more uniform.

  • Imitation opals: Fashion-only pieces made from glass or resin, lacking the richness and dimension of the real thing.

Think of real opals as couture gowns — each one is different. Lab opals are beautifully made designer recreations, while imitations are fast-fashion copies.

Style Clues to Spot a Genuine Opal

When shopping, here’s what to notice — both as a jewelry lover and as someone who values style:

  • Play of color: True opals shimmer and shift with every movement, catching light from every angle. Fake ones often look flat, like a print rather than a painting.

  • Pattern uniqueness: Natural opals have one-of-a-kind swirls, streaks, or flashes. If the design repeats too perfectly, it’s probably not natural.

  • Depth of design: Authentic opals seem to hold light beneath their surface, creating a layered, almost three-dimensional glow.

  • Back of the stone: Genuine opals may show uneven surfaces or natural host rock, adding authenticity and charm.

Style insight: Pairing a genuine opal with clean, modern settings (like sleek bezels in yellow or white gold) lets the stone’s natural depth do the talking.

Natural vs. Lab-Created: Style Perspectives

Both natural and lab-created opals are real, but they lend themselves to slightly different jewelry expressions:

  • Natural opals – Ideal for collectors and lovers of organic beauty. Their irregular patterns make them perfect for bespoke designs where no two pieces are alike.

  • Lab-created opals – Brighter, more uniform, and often bolder. These shine in fashion-forward designs like stackable rings or contemporary earrings, where symmetry and color consistency enhance the look.

Neither is “better” — it comes down to how you want to express your style.

Imitation Opals: Pretty but Not the Same

Imitation opals can be fun for casual fashion pieces, but they lack the fire and prestige of genuine stones.

  • Opalite glass: Milky or bluish, trendy in boho jewelry, but without true play of color.

  • Resin-based opals: Lightweight, glittery, and often flashy — but unmistakably costume jewelry.

  • Doublets and triplets: Thin slices of real opal layered with backing or quartz. More affordable but not solid opals.

If you want jewelry that feels timeless and worthy of passing down, always lean toward natural or lab-created opals.

Subtle Signs Experts Look For

For style lovers, the focus is on color and beauty. But behind the scenes, jewelers like Plateau Jewelers use subtle indicators:

  • Microscopic growth lines in lab opals.

  • Tiny mineral inclusions in natural opals.

  • Brightness and uniformity often higher in lab opals.

These are details you can’t spot at home — but they matter when authenticity is part of your jewelry’s value.

FAQs About Real Opals

Do real opals only come in white?

No. Black opals, fire opals, and boulder opals offer colors ranging from deep midnight blues to glowing orange.

Are lab opals good for jewelry?

Absolutely. They’re real opals, just grown differently. Many fashion designers use them in bold, modern collections.

What’s the most timeless opal style?

A solitaire opal ring or pendant in yellow gold is a classic. For trendsetters, stacked opal bands or opal-and-diamond combos add flair.

Conclusion: Style and Authenticity Go Hand in Hand

So, how do you tell if an opal is real? By looking for depth, uniqueness, and color play — the hallmarks of a stone with character. Natural and lab-created opals both deliver authentic beauty, while imitations fall short of the magic.

At Plateau Jewelers in Sammamish, WA, we bring together gemological expertise and design artistry to help you find opal jewelry that matches your style. From custom designs to timeless heirlooms, we’ll help you choose pieces that shine as brightly as you do.

Explore Opal Jewelry at Plateau Jewelers

Back to News